home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- From: john@rtfm.mlb.fl.us (John Blasik)
- Newsgroups: alt.drugs,talk.politics.drugs
- Subject: "...but i didn't swear at them"
- Message-ID: <1991Oct13.050259.4326@rtfm.mlb.fl.us>
- Date: 13 Oct 91 05:02:59 GMT
-
- This story appeared in the Florida TODAY "The Space Coast's Newspaper"
- on October 11, 1991
-
- Typos are probably my fault.
-
- File this under "Colateral damage of the War on Drugs"
- -- john
-
-
- $700,000 civil suit sprouts from `marijuana' raid
-
-
- Associated Press
- ORLANDO -- They sure looked like marijuana plants.
-
- At least that's what Orange County Deputy John Brick was thinking
- when he ordered five members of the Carden family to lay face down in
- their back yard while he called for help.
-
- Brick handcuffed several family members, pointed his gun at a
- 5-year-old boy and his grandfather, and cursed at them repeatedly,
- the family said.
-
- It took another hour and the arrival of dozens of other deputies
- before an officer realized the demon weeds were actually wild
- elderberry plants.
-
- "I believed they were pot plants until my sergeant told me they
- weren't. I honestly made a mistake, and I learned from it," Brick
- said.
-
- Brick said he apologized for the incident. Later, his supervisors
- mailed a letter of apology to the family. But the Carden family said
- the raid was more than a mistake -- it violated their constitutional
- rights.
-
- Thursday, [Oct. 10 -- jb], they formally notified the sheriff's
- office they intend to sue for $700,000.
-
- "I'm never going to get over what happened," said Jan Carden, who
- owns the property with her husband, Ed. "It was like we were on the
- set of `Miami Vice.'"
-
- Brick, who was disciplined for not immediately calling for backup,
- said he didn't realize he he needed a warrant to look for pot in the
- woods, and didn't realize he was in someone's back yard.
-
- He also denied swearing at the family. "If they say that happened,
- it's going to be a lie," said Brick, who is 28 and a 6-1/2 year
- veteran deputy.
-
- After spotting the plants, Brick said he noticed the Carden's
- son-in-law, Russell Smith looking at him from a nearby trailer.
- Brick ordered Smith, 25, and his sister-in-law, Carmel Carden,15, to
- to the ground.
-
- Then three more family members walked by. Brick ordered them face
- down as well. When little Joshua Carden ran to his grandfather
- instead, Brick became agitated and trained his gun on the boy, said
- Roger Poirier, 54. "I said, `Are you crazy? That's my grandson, and
- he's 5 years old!' " said Poirier, Jan Carden's father.
-
- Brick acknowledged the he was "probably a little excited."
-
- "When I saw the man in the trailer, I thought `Now is the time to
- take him down. I can't give him a chance to shoot me,'" he said. "I
- just wanted to secure everything so I didn't get hurt.
-
- "At the time, I honestly believed the plants were marijuana, and I
- was facing five or six of them and just me"
-